Page 3 of 5 <12345>
Topic Options
Rate This Topic
#180164 - 04/12/17 12:41 PM Re: Fast 357 versus a slow 44? [Re: tradmark]
Ernie
Distinguished Expert


Registered: 01/18/04
Posts: 4628
Loc: Gillette, Wyoming

Offline
Here is the OP's question.
"What say you, if you had the choice between the two for 50ish+ yard deer would you prefer a fast 357 or a slow 44?"

50 yard range, I doubt the deer is going to know the difference.
Preference!
Get what YOU want!!!
_________________________
Ernie

Top
#180166 - 04/12/17 02:32 PM Re: Fast 357 versus a slow 44? [Re: Ernie]
tradmark
Pooh-Bah


Registered: 06/08/10
Posts: 1878

Offline
The deer will on any marginal hits.

Top
#180168 - 04/12/17 03:59 PM Re: Fast 357 versus a slow 44? [Re: tradmark]
Ernie
Distinguished Expert


Registered: 01/18/04
Posts: 4628
Loc: Gillette, Wyoming

Offline
Agreed, and I would say as much about any straight wall case (or bottleneck), depending what the definition of marginal is.
_________________________
Ernie

Top
#180170 - 04/12/17 06:58 PM Re: Fast 357 versus a slow 44? [Re: Ernie]
tradmark
Pooh-Bah


Registered: 06/08/10
Posts: 1878

Offline
my definition on marginal is if it's hit in a way that will kill the animal but not before it makes it over the fence to the property i can't follow it on about 150 yards away, or in the case of prince of wales island, hit fatally but not soon enough to keep it from making it to the trees. not sure i understood you post or not, but what about any straight walled case?

Top
#180175 - 04/12/17 08:28 PM Re: Fast 357 versus a slow 44? [Re: tradmark]
Whitworth
Shootist


Registered: 01/15/09
Posts: 8844
Loc: Virginia

content Online
Yeah, that straight-walled case comment has my curiosity piqued as well. I haven't found straight-walled cases lacking in terminal effectiveness in the least. It all boils down to placement and the correct bullet.
_________________________

Max Prasac

Semper Fidelis

The Gun Digest Book of Hunting Revolvers:
https://youtu.be/zKJbjjPaNUE

"Building Carpal Tunnel one round at a time"

Top
#180199 - 04/13/17 09:08 AM Re: Fast 357 versus a slow 44? [Re: Whitworth]
Ernie
Distinguished Expert


Registered: 01/18/04
Posts: 4628
Loc: Gillette, Wyoming

Offline
"Any straight wall case" would be ones that you would use for deer sized game, just as bottleneck cases would be the same...The ones you use to hunt with.

Tradmark, thanks for your definition of "marginal."
My point was, a bad shot is a bad shot, regardless of straight wall or bottleneck cartridges one would use for game.
I have seen animals go quite a ways with both lungs blown out while others go down quickly, and others between the two.
I would not have considered a double lung shot marginal.
When I hunted in SC, the owner of the property wanted me to double shoulder shoot all deer for the expressed purpose of not having to track them in heavy cover.

Totally agree with this: "It all boils down to placement and the correct bullet."
_________________________
Ernie

Top
#180201 - 04/13/17 10:16 AM Re: Fast 357 versus a slow 44? [Re: Ernie]
Whitworth
Shootist


Registered: 01/15/09
Posts: 8844
Loc: Virginia

content Online
And the biggest truism is, every animal is a law unto itself.....
_________________________

Max Prasac

Semper Fidelis

The Gun Digest Book of Hunting Revolvers:
https://youtu.be/zKJbjjPaNUE

"Building Carpal Tunnel one round at a time"

Top
#180202 - 04/13/17 10:24 AM Re: Fast 357 versus a slow 44? [Re: Whitworth]
Ernie
Distinguished Expert


Registered: 01/18/04
Posts: 4628
Loc: Gillette, Wyoming

Offline
YES!
_________________________
Ernie

Top
#180206 - 04/13/17 01:53 PM Re: Fast 357 versus a slow 44? [Re: Ernie]
N-Frame
journeyman


Registered: 03/11/16
Posts: 50

Offline
So, if we are comparing .357 mag to .44 Spl, what, exactly are we comparing? The .357 is a known quantity, but what sort of .44 Spl ammo are we comparing it to?

Top
#180222 - 04/14/17 07:24 AM Re: Fast 357 versus a slow 44? [Re: tradmark]
billa
addict


Registered: 02/12/05
Posts: 537
Loc: Central PA

Offline
I would go with the 44 Special. Sounds like a great all around packin gun!
_________________________
"Therefore go and make disciples of all nations,... "
Matthew 28:19

Handgun hunter since 1979 - haven't used a rifle since!
HHI member #992, NRA, SCI.

Top
Page 3 of 5 <12345>


Moderator:  Gary, jamesfromjersey, Dan B., ClayFHT, Gregg Richter 
Hop to:
 Portal Sidebar
Who's Online
6 registered (Zee, Whitworth, KRal, Spencer, Newt, thadf) and 118 anonymous users online.
Top Posters
9009
s4s4u
8844
Whitworth
7641
wapitirod
7341
jamesfromjersey
7327
TCTex.
5790
KRal
4980
Gary
4704
Tigger
4628
Ernie
4370
Dan B.
3755
johnwilliams
3710
pab1
3677
Gregg Richter
3548
TN Lone Wolf
3341
Raptortrapper
  Member Hunts
First Handgun Deer
First Handgun Deer

Hunting with Doug
Hunting with Doug Wesson and the .357

   Access Requires Login

Generated in 0.044 seconds in which 0.008 seconds were spent on a total of 14 queries. Zlib compression enabled.




Copyright © 2000-2008
HandgunHunt.com, Inc.